What if the Jets had signed Derek Carr instead of trading for Aaron Rodgers two years ago?

After the 2022 season, the New York Jets sought a veteran quarterback, narrowing their options to Aaron Rodgers and Derek Carr. Initially, Rodgers seemed unattainable, while Carr appeared a more practical choice. The Jets courted Carr, emphasizing their plans to leverage his experience and help mentor Zach Wilson. Despite a promising meeting, Carr signed with the Saints after feeling like a secondary option to Rodgers. Rodgers eventually joined the Jets, but his stint was marked by setbacks, including an Achilles injury that derailed the team's offense. The Jets finished the season with unremarkable stats, leaving fans wondering if choosing Carr might have led to a less dramatic and more successful outcome. Carr retired in 2025 due to injury, while the Jets continue searching for a solution to their quarterback woes with Justin Fields.